Skip to main content

Delinquent Future?

My brain requested me to let it go on a vacation...So I listened and went on a sabbatical. I hope you missed me!

Much has changed - both in India and globally - since my last post. Markets around the globe seem to have caught a collective cold. I am probably feeling happy after quite a while in the markets, with so much pessimism going around. The markets have now tuned their radars to pick up the slightest of negative news flows to go on a free fall.


In this post, I take a look at some interesting developments in delinquency rates related to real estate and the response of the equity markets (S&P 500). Admittedly there are number of factors that have a bearing on the movement of the S&P 500 and one cannot see the causal effect of one on another in isolation. But as they say…sometimes the part is better than the whole…especially when trying to get a sense of how things fit together to form the larger picture!


Delinquency rates – to put it crudely – measures how many loans default as a proportion of total loans outstanding. The more people default higher is the delinquency rate. Why would people default? Simple, an economy goes into a tailspin --> people lose jobs --> low or no income --> can’t meet monthly loan payments --> increase in defaults --> higher delinquency rates.

What could be the relationship between delinquency rates and equity markets? One line of reasoning goes this way. Increase in delinquency rates --> people have less money to spend --> decrease in consumer spending --> liquidating of investments to meet important outflows --> collective negativity leads to slowdown in corporate earnings --> decreased stock prices.

Again, what is the cause and what is the effect is a debatable issue here. Here is a chart depicting the movement of the S&P 500 and movement in delinquency rates for real estate, residential and commercial properties.

Back in 2000, delinquency rates had just begun to rise and peaked in early 2001. What happened to equities? The S&P peaked just as delinquency rates started rising and then went into a free fall. The excessive froth that built up during the internet bubble took quite some time to settle down and the S&P continued its down trend till mid-2002.

Post 2001, delinquency rates started falling as the Fed intervened and cut interest rates. Interest rate cuts stimulate the economy, leading to a virtuous cycle of positive things resulting to a bull run in equities.

Looking at the low interest rates several players entered the real estate market with dollar signs in their eyes. They thought that the only way home prices could move was up and they leveraged themselves…well almost…to buy their dream home! But as they say all good things come to an end and this housing bubble too…

…The uptrend in the S&P which began in mid-2002 continued over the next five years. However interest rates were continuously rising during this time as the Fed worried about several things, not in the least among these being the build up of a possible housing bubble. Somebody had finally arrived to spoil the party. The continuously rising interest rates gradually led to a rise in defaults as people started feeling the pinch of costlier money. But somehow the equity markets were still oblivious to this development and continued rising…

Then suddenly – as always – the markets woke up and saw the above chart. Delinquency rates were at 8/9 year highs and everyone started wondering why on earth they were loading up on equities…

And the S&P started dropping...

2008 has been a forgettable year for most global markets. The fall in the S&P has triggered a fall in equity markets around the globe due to the coupling effect. What remains an unanswered question is whether the end 2007 peak will mark a repeat of the 2000 peak. Because if it does then those unfortunate people who correctly picked the top are in for a one way ride. Everyone says equities are one of the best asset classes in the long run. Ask a guy who picked the 2000 peak and see if you get the same answer. There is nothing that makes an asset class inherently good. Price paid is everything…

Delinquency rates have never been higher in the past 8/9 years but the S&P touched about the same level seen in 2000. The housing trouble seems far from over and a recession is almost the grim consensus currently. So till that time equity markets could be in for a choppy ride with an increased inclination to moving south rather than north. But there will be pockets of value waiting to be picked. One just needs to be patient and keep looking…

In the complex web of interconnected linkages, it is extremely tough to isolate one factor as the cause that leads to A, then B and then C. However, certain ‘indicators’ stick out like a sore thumb when overlapped with another. Delinquency rates and equities is one example. Credit spreads and equities are another. (For the curious: Check out this earlier post where I first played Dr. Doom. The S&P was at ~1520 then, its at 1380 now.)

I am fascinated and interested in unearthing these relationships. My other idol, the physicist Richard Feynman used to say this about physics – and something that is true in investing too –


“It’s all about asking the right questions and to keep looking. You do an experiment not with the intention of proving your prophecy but to learn about reality. This integrity will lead you to ask questions that you would have never thought of asking otherwise. In the process you unearth something about the way Nature works…it is fascinating!”

I totally agree.

I will never claim to ‘predicting’ market levels. I cannot do that. I don’t know how to do that. But by continuously looking at things that might have a bearing on each other I maximize my chances of staying out of big trouble.

As my guru, Warren Buffett says,

“I have made money by staying out of trouble.”

Pearls of wisdom from God himself.

Comments

dexkid said…
Nice post after a long time.
Anonymous said…
When the whole mkt was sinking, I really missed ur article …as usual its very nice…
Relationship between delinquency rates and equity markets is very well explained...

also, i liked the last para of the article...
“I will never claim to ‘predicting’ market levels. I cannot do that. I don’t know how to do that. But by continuously looking at things that might have a bearing on each other I maximize my chances of staying out of big trouble.”
Thanks both of you!

Anon...it would be nice if you could reveal your identity. Would love to stay in touch!

- HS

Popular posts from this blog

Book review: In the Long Run we are all Dead

In the Long Run we are all Dead: A Macroeconomics murder mystery The US economy faces a deep recession, raging inflation and an impending run on the dollar. President Wedik likes economics as much as a fish likes land. Should he listen to the Keynesians, who favour government intervention or the Monetarists, who favour market fundamentalism?

Unable to decide, he delegates the tough decision to his Chief of Staff, Admiral Harcourt Green. Green laboriously goes through the process of coming up with an economic policy package...only to be mysteriously murdered on D-day. Details of the economic package dies with him...
Something has to be done soon to avoid an economic collapse. What? How?
Who committed the murder? And why?
The murder story could probably have been constructed better but the crux of the book is economics! Recommend it to those looking for a light read on macroeconomics without running the risk of drowning in jargon.
In this delightfully light read, Wolfson & Buranelli, weav…

Napoleon’s Lucky Generals: "I know he's a good general, but is he lucky?"

With most market participants making money this year, the timeless quote by Napoleon in the subject line rears its head, once again. Regular non-readers know the wonderment I have on the impact of luck on investment outcomes.
The markets have been on a tear (sure you didn’t notice), and my mailbox/chat is seeing two polarized stances. On one side is the Bullish Apology. Where market participants pre-emptively share justifications for continued strong markets everywhere. This group exhibits hyper optimism, using recent history as the periscope through which to peer at and gauge the future. 
The second, and potentially, the more interesting group, is the Bubble Babble crowd. This group looks askance at the rallies, and deems things a bubble. This year has given this group a great polarizer. Bitcoin. A tiny bit know much about it. Most know a bit about it; yet there is a growing supply of those sharing their two coins, calling Bitcoin a bubble.
Both groups share certain characteristics. The…

Halls of the Blind

I can see what you see not Vision milky, then eyes rot. When you turn, they will be gone, Whispering their hidden song. Then you see what cannot be Shadows move where light should be. Out of darkness, out of mind, Cast down into the Halls of the Blind. 

- Diablo


I usually avoid referring to stuff from the 90s as the opening act. It risks giving away my vintage…
But the above words from one of the most successful role-playing games from the 90s – Diablo – (who remembers it?) is apt for this edition.
Auditor Problems.
It’s an opportune moment to dive into the Corporate Halls of the Blind.
*****
Indian markets have been beset by a sudden wave of auditor resignations from listed companies in recent times. Stock prices of the affected companies have taken a beating. Runaway auditors have caused market participants to speculate over the next defection, as alpha monkeys smell quick gains. Auditor issues have surfaced after a period of widespread price correction. Wounded consciences that were assuaged by …